Find Your Perfect Policy: 866-843-5386

Last updated: March 9, 2023

Dairyland Car Insurance Pricing 2022

Explore possible rates and our favorite features from Dairyland.

Twitter brand
Facebook brand
Linkedin brand
Reddit brand
Envelop icon

As a nonstandard insurer, Dairyland specializes in motorcycle and auto coverage for people who might have difficulty obtaining policies elsewhere. If you have a poor driving record, little experience, or no prior car insurance, Dairyland could be a smart option. This page details the basics of Dairyland and what you can expect to pay so you can make the best auto insurance choice for you.

Car Insurance Rates for Dairyland Insurance Coverage

Dairyland’s average annual cost for auto insurance is $2,105. You could pay as little as $1,560 or as much as $4,008 annually. This yearly average is a bit higher than most insurance companies’ averages because Dairyland is a nonstandard insurer. Nonstandard insurance covers drivers who are too financially risky to cover at standard rates.

You may be a high-risk driver if you:

  • Have a poor driving record
  • Don’t have prior insurance
  • Have a history of accidents
  • Don’t have driving experience
  • Are an elderly driver (75 years old or older)

Your exact premium will depend on personal factors such as the coverage you’re seeking and your driving history. Here are car insurance premiums for different driver profiles:

  • Minimum coverage: The average annual cost for minimum coverage is $1,790.
  • Full coverage: The average cost jumps significantly to $4,242 yearly for full coverage insurance.
  • Teenagers: Young drivers can expect to pay $3,924 on average for annual coverage.
  • Seniors: If you have years of driving experience, your average rates drop to $1,152 a year.
  • At-fault accident: The average annual cost of a full coverage policy increases to $5,817 after one at-fault accident. Learn more about the cost of car insurance with accidents.

To find out your auto insurance premium from Dairyland, get a car insurance quote from an agent.

Discounts With Dairyland

Discount type Discount qualification
Multi-car If you have multiple vehicles in your household that you want to include on your policy
Advanced quote If you get a quote at least a week in advance from the day you need your insurance coverage to begin
Transfer If you’ve had auto insurance from another provider for at least 6 months and start a new policy with Dairyland
Payment frequency If you pay more than the minimum down payment and make your payments quarterly, every 6 months, or every year
Homeowners If you own or rent a home; the discount for renters is not available in all states
Defensive driving If you complete a defensive driving course
Anti-theft If you secure your vehicle with an anti-theft device(s)1

Favorite Features

SR-22 Insurance

Dairyland offers SR-22 coverage for car owners and nonowners. An SR-22 is a form that shows the state that you have met the minimum auto liability insurance requirements.

You may need an SR-22 if you have:

  • A DUI conviction
  • A conviction for driving with an expired or invalid license
  • Serious and/or multiple traffic violations
  • Too many moving violations within a year
  • An at-fault accident while driving without insurance


You will not handle an SR-22 form yourself. If a court or the state orders you to file an SR-22, your insurance company will file the form on your behalf with your DMV.

Superior Financial Strength

Since 1992, Dairyland has received an A+ rating from AM Best, indicating superior financial strength. Financial strength ratings demonstrate a company’s ability to meet ongoing insurance obligations such as claim payouts.

Extra Coverage Options

Alongside Dairyland’s basic coverage options like bodily injury and property damage coverage, which cover damages and losses of the other party in an accident, the company offers extra add-on coverage options, such as:

  • Comprehensive coverage
  • Collision coverage
  • Rental reimbursement
  • Roadside assistance
  • Special equipment protection: This coverage protects permanent, custom modifications to your vehicle with parts that weren’t factory installed.

Easy-to-Use Mobile App

Dairyland’s mobile app offers complete access to self-service options for iOS and Android users. Stay up to date on all your account information, such as:

Where Is Dairyland Available?

Dairyland is licensed to provide insurance in 22 states:

  • Alaska
  • Arizona
  • California
  • Colorado
  • Idaho
  • Illinois
  • Montana
  • Nevada
  • New Mexico
  • New York
  • North Carolina
  • North Dakota
  • Ohio
  • Oregon
  • Pennsylvania
  • Tennessee
  • Texas
  • Utah
  • Washington
  • West Virginia
  • Wisconsin
  • Wyoming2

Cancellation Policy

To cancel your policy with Dairyland, call its customer service line at 800-334-0090.

You may face a cancellation fee for ending your policy before your renewal date, but ask an agent for a prorated refund. If you paid in full, a prorated refund would return any unused premium for the remaining days in your policy period.


Make sure you have a new policy before you cancel your current one. A lapse in coverage could leave you financially unprotected in the event of an accident and potentially increase your future insurance premiums.

Company Background

  • 1953: The company was formed as Dairyland Mutual Insurance Company of Wisconsin and began selling specialty insurance to dairy farmers.
  • 1966: Sentry Insurance acquired Dairyland.
  • 1975: Independent agents joined the Dairyland team.
  • 2005: Sentry acquired Viking Insurance and merged it with Dairyland, doubling the size of its specialty auto insurance services.
  • 2022: From its Midwestern roots, Dairyland has expanded its local presence for over 60 years to provide insurance coverage to more than 20 states.

Dairyland Contact Information

If you are trying to make a payment or receive a quote, Dairyland’s website is the go-to tool for 24/7 access to your account details and inquiries. If you would rather reach out by phone or email, you can use these contacts:

  1. For quotes: Call 844-933-4445 for auto insurance or 844-906-3477 for motorcycle insurance on weekdays from 6 a.m. to 9 p.m. CT and on Saturdays from 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. CT.
  2. For policy questions, claims service, and payments: Call 800-334-0090 or email, 24/7.
  3. To report suspected fraud: Call 877-736-8798 or email
  4. For online inquiries: Fill out the email form on Dairyland’s contact page: Expect a response within 24 to 48 hours.
  5. For social media: Follow @DairylandCycle on Facebook, @dairylandins on Twitter, @dairylandmotorcycle on Instagram, and Dairyland on YouTube.



While its premium rates run higher than average, Dairyland is an excellent option for high-risk drivers searching for discounts and SR-22 coverage for cars and motorcycles. If you live in one of the states that Dairyland serves, you should consider its mobile app and additional coverage options when searching for the best auto insurer.

Frequently Asked Questions

What types of car insurance coverage does Dairyland offer?

Dairyland offers liability, uninsured motorist (UM), underinsured motorist (UIM), personal injury protection (PIP), medical payments, collision, comprehensive, towing and labor, rental reimbursement, lienholder, and special equipment coverage.

What happens during Dairyland’s claim process?

Dairyland is present at every step of the claims process. After you report your auto claim, an agent will ask some initial questions to connect you with a claims associate. The claims associate will review your policy and determine the next steps and payouts. If you require repairs or a rental car during your claims process, Dairyland will connect you with a repair shop and rental service (if you have rental coverage on your policy).

If your policy covers your claim, you’ll receive a check from Dairyland directly. If your policy does not cover your claim, you will receive a letter detailing the reasoning for the denial. Depending on your state’s laws, you can choose to file an appeal if you believe the denial is inaccurate.

How do I find a Dairyland agent near me?

To find a Dairyland agent near you:

  1. Visit Dairyland’s website:
  2. Click “Find An Agent.”
  3. Enter your ZIP code.
  4. Choose either auto or motorcycle coverage.
  5. Enter the radius in miles within which you want to search.
  6. Submit your search. A list of any available agents will populate in order of proximity to your ZIP code.

What off-road vehicles does Dairyland insure?

Dairyland provides off-road vehicle insurance for ATV/UTVs, dirt bikes, side-by-sides, and snowmobiles.


  1. Save money with our auto insurance discounts. Dairyland. (2022).

  2. NAIC numbers and state licenses. Sentry.