AssuranceAmerica is a small regional provider, so there aren’t any ratings from third parties like J.D. Power or CRASH Network. To get a sense of customer satisfaction, I looked at their complaint score and actual customer reviews.
AssuranceAmerica holds a score of 3.15 on The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) Complaint Index. On this metric, lower scores are better, and the average is 1. That means AssuranceAmerica received three times the number of complaints as similarly sized companies. When I filtered the results to private passenger insurance only, the score improved to 1.89, which translates to a slightly higher-than-average number of complaints.
I also looked at AssuranceAmerica’s Better Business Bureau (BBB) ratings. I found two separate BBB profiles: one with an “A” rating and one with an “F” rating. Both profiles had similar reviews, which pointed to company practices that gave me pause. These were the most common complaints:
- Being overcharged for monthly premiums
- Being charged after canceling a policy, and not getting a refund
- Receiving poor customer and claims service
- Having difficulty reaching claims adjusters and receiving payouts
It looks like many customers had less-than-satisfactory experiences with AssuranceAmerica. Multiple reviews mentioned being overcharged and not being able to get a refund. Others reported contacting AssuranceAmerica to subrogate a claim (since their customer was at fault) but couldn’t get ahold of anyone, despite calling multiple times.
| Category | Rating |
|---|
| NAIC | 3.15 (more complaints than average)1 |
| BBB | 1 out of 5 stars (average of 42 reviews across both profiles)23 |
I also noticed that AssuranceAmerica didn’t have any financial strength ratings. That’s important to consider when you’re choosing a provider, since it speaks to whether the company has the monetary backing to fulfill claims.